Hanover, Indiana

Hanover College is often remembered as one of the many local casualties of the 1974 Super Outbreak, along with the IKE Power Plant, Clifty Falls State Park, the local schools, and many nearby homes and buildings. At 3:51pm on April 3, 1974, one of two F4 tornadoes beginning near Madison made its way onto Hanover’s campus, destroying more than 30 buildings and causing $10 million in damage. “The tornado looked like two clouds going in circles about 200 feet high. They were dark green,” recalls an anonymous student in an interview for The Hanoverian, Hanover College’s residential magazine.
“The most unsettling experience were the roll calls,” another student, Kristen Gable, admits in a 50th anniversary memorial collection created by the Hanover College Archives. “They would call off the names of dorm residents who were not yet accounted for. Hearing each name, especially those of particularly close friends, made my heart sink and my imagination run wild.”

These two recollections are just a few of many similar stories told by former students of Hanover College, many of whom witnessed the tornado firsthand. Though the tornado that struck Hanover College was responsible for 190 injuries and 11 deaths, no one on campus was killed, although several were seriously injured. Despite the massive destruction, the community that grew around the tornadic event is looked back on somewhat fondly by those who experienced it. “There were a lot of people who showed great courage and compassion during this time. The feeling of community was enormous everywhere you went,” recalled former student James Struck. Former president John Horner seemed to agree, stating in his personal notes: “The tornado was also the most cohesive [event] in the life of the college. It brought more unity to the campus than one could ever imagine. The team spirit was genuine and long-lasting. Everyone ‘pulled together’ for the common good.”

Images

The Tornado
The Tornado A photograph of the F4 tornado that decimated many structures in Madison and Hanover, Indiana, including those on the college campus. Hanover College suffered nearly $10 million in losses, as well as 80% of their trees and foliage. Source: Hanover College Archives PH39_Box1_F034 Creator: Hanover College Date: 1974
Aerial View (1974)<br />
Aerial View (1974)
An aerial view of the campus shortly after the tornado passed through. Notice the toppled buildings and debris that has been dragged several feet through the open area. Source: Hanover College Archives BW00 752 268 Creator: Hanover College Date: 1974
Aerial View (2014)
Aerial View (2014) What do Mike Pence, Eric Holcomb, and Woody Harrelson have in common? Besides the first two men acting as the most recent Indiana governors, all three are alumni of Hanover College, a small liberal arts school nestled in the heart of the Ohio River Valley. Just a few miles south of Historic Madison, IN, Hanover College was founded in 1827 by Reverend John Finley Crowe, a Presbyterian minister, and is the oldest private college in Indiana.What began as a single brick building along the banks of the Ohio River has grown into highly successful liberal arts institution that has served the area for almost 200 years. Source: Wikimedia Commons Creator: Hanover College Office of Communications and Marketing Date: 2014
Faculty Response
Faculty Response John Horner, president of the college, discusses next steps with Dean Glen Bonsett and a group of students immediately following the tornado’s destruction. Debris, strewn branches, and fallen trees are visible in the background behind the group of men. Source: Hanover College Archives BW00 752 28 Creator: Hanover College Date: 1974
Phi Mu Destroyed
Phi Mu Destroyed Phi Mu Sorority House was one of at least 30 buildings on Hanover’s Campus destroyed partially or completely by the tornado. One of four sorority houses available for students to join, Phi Mu remains a staple of Hanover College culture. Shortly after the tornado, the building was restored to its original state, and continues to serve as Phi Mu’s home. Source: Hanover College Archives BW00 752 187 Creator: Hanover College Date: 1974
Water Tower
Water Tower The remains of Hanover College’s water tower, another victim of the tornado. Part of the name of the college can be seen printed on the warped metal casing. Source: Hanover College Archives BW00 752 153
Creator: Frank Baker, Hanover College Date: 1974

Location

517 Ball Drive

Metadata

Katie Philiposian, “Hanover, Indiana,” Discover Indiana, accessed October 22, 2026, https://discoverindianahistory.org.curatescape7.reclaim.hosting/items/show/628.