Filed Under Story

Lyles Station

Before Lyles Station was known by its current name, it was called the Switch Settlement. The first individuals to settle in this area were Joshua Lyles, the namesake of Lyles Station, and his brother Sanford. Raised in Virginia, the Lyles brothers moved to Tennessee before traveling with a group of Quakers to settle in Indiana sometime in the late 1830s to early 40s. By the 1860s, the Lyles brothers’ holdings measured up to hundreds of acres of farmland.

The area’s population expanded over time. Families of free and formerly enslaved people arrived in the area, epting the safety and shelter that Joshua Lyles and the other settlers offered them. Following the American Civil War, Lyles Station saw an even larger increase in residents.

To accompany the community’s growth, Lyles Station also saw the formation and establishment of a local church, Hardshell Baptist Church, and a subscription school to serve their local community. A subscription school was a form of informal schoolhouse, usually with one teacher, where families could pay per day and per person for their children to receive an education. Rural communities would typically pay one adult to teach for a few months a year in order for children to learn basic reading and math.

In 1870, Joshua Lyles donated some of his land in order to build a local stop for the Old Airline Railroad on the Louisville-St. Lois railroad line. This line made export of crops from local farms much easier. One year after Joshua’s death in 1885, the community was officially incorporated, meaning the community received permission from the state government to form their own local government. Both the rail station and the community itself became known as Lyles Station.

Images

School & Museum
School & Museum Pictured above is the Lyles Station School and Museum. The Lyles Station Historic Preservation Corporation (LSHPC), a not-for-profit organization dedicated to preserving the history of Lyles Station, acquired the Lyles Consolidated School to restore it, and this location is now home to a museum focused on Lyles Station history. Source: Lyles Station
Lyles Marker 1
Lyles Marker 1 Pictured is the first side of the historic marker for Lyles Station. The marker reads “Settled in late 1840s by Joshua and Sanford Lyles, former slaves from Tennessee. African Methodist Episcopal Church (since 1860) and schools (1865-1958) played important roles in sustaining the community. On land donated by Joshua Lyles, railroad companies maintained a station from the 1870s to the 1950s for passenger, freight, and mail service.” Source: Indiana Historical Bureau
Lyles Marker 2
Lyles Marker 2 Pictured is the second side of the historic marker for Lyles Station. The marker reads “Named Lyles Station 1886. Community declined after widespread flooding in 1913. It remains probably most intact African-American settlement in the state; several present residents are descendants of original settlers. Lyles Consolidated School, built 1919, listed in National Register of Historic Places 1999; restoration began 2001.” Source: Indiana Historical Bureau

Location

953 N. 500 W., Princeton, IN 47670

Metadata

Samantha Rice, “Lyles Station,” Discover Indiana, accessed October 22, 2026, https://discoverindianahistory.org.curatescape7.reclaim.hosting/items/show/706.